Subscribe to DSC Newsletter

Curious Mathematical Problem

Let us consider the following equation:

Prove that

  • x = log(Pi) = 1.14472988584... is a very good approximation of a solution, up to 10 digits.
  • Using high performance computing or other means, prove that it is correct up to 1,000 digits.
  • Is x = log(Pi) an exact solution?

If the answer to the last question is positive, this would mean that log(Pi) is NOT a transcendental number, but rather, an algebraic number. A remarkable result in itself!

Source for picture: algebraic numbers

Solution and related problem

Any real number larger or equal to 1 is a solution, so there is nothing particular with log(Pi). A more subtle version of this problem is to ask the student to solve the following equation:

We know from the previous problem that if x^5 - x^2 - 1 = x^2 - 1, the equality holds. Thus to find a solution, we just need to solve x^5 - x^2 - 1 = x^2 - 1. The cubic root of 2 is a solution.

More generally, let's define

Then the (unique) real-valued solution to the equation f(x) = 0 is given by

In particular, if p = 3, then x = 2. If p = 2 + log(2) / log(3), then x = 3. Note that the function f is monotonic, and thus invertible. What is the inverse of f?

Another curious problem 

Find an exact,non-trivial solution to the following equation:

sin x + sin(2x sin x) = sin 3x.

This is part of a general type of equations, namely f(x) + f(x f(x)) = 2 f(1), where one of the solutions must of course also be solution of f(x) = 1. Here, f(x) = 2 sin x, and thus x = Pi / 6 is a solution. See plot of sin x + sin(2x sin x) - sin 3x, below.

For related articles from the same author, click here or visit www.VincentGranville.com. Follow me on on LinkedIn, or visit my old web page here.

DSC Resources

Views: 1376

Comment

You need to be a member of AnalyticBridge to add comments!

Join AnalyticBridge

Comment by Vincent Granville on September 1, 2018 at 8:31am

A reader posted the following comment:

I think this is a really neat example, a great problem to give to high school students. To solve it, notice that the first two square roots look like sqrt(x + z) - sqrt(x - z). Call this y. Simple algebra gives y = +-sqrt(2x +- 2). Plug in a value, say x = 2, and the answer must be sqrt(2x - 2) as claimed.

Going deeper, let's turn this into a polynomial system. Let z = sqrt(x2 - 1), w = sqrt(2x - 2), v = sqrt(x - z), u = sqrt(x + z). Then we have a system of five equations

(Set each to 0). Use the Dixon resultant to eliminate u, v, w, z. The answer is that x = 1; that is, x must be 1. But this is false! Why? Because the solution is not 0-dimensional. Dixon doesn't have to work then. Nice example.

Resources

On Data Science Central

© 2020   AnalyticBridge.com is a subsidiary and dedicated channel of Data Science Central LLC   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service